Our Blogs

Mild Steel vs. Carbon Steel: Which One Should You Use?

When selecting materials for manufacturing, fabrication, or construction, steel is often the go-to choice. But even within the category of steel, there are important distinctions to consider. Two of the most common options are mild steel and carbon steel. While they may look similar at first glance, each has its own set of characteristics, strengths, and ideal applications.

In this blog, we will delve deep into the comparison of mild steel vs carbon steel, explore their properties, uses, and specifications, and help you determine which material is the right fit for your project.

What is Mild Steel?

Mild steel is a type of low-carbon steel, typically containing between 0.05% and 0.25% carbon. It is known for its excellent ductility, weldability, and versatility. The relatively low carbon content makes it softer and more malleable compared to other types of steel.

Mild Steel Properties

Some of the most notable mild steel properties include high ductility, good machinability, and ease of welding. It can be bent or shaped without cracking, which is why it's so widely used across different industries. Additionally, mild steel is magnetic and relatively inexpensive.

Because of its low hardness, mild steel can wear more quickly than higher-carbon steels. However, its ability to be easily fabricated makes it an excellent choice for applications that do not require high strength or wear resistance.

Mild Steel Specification

The mild steel specification varies slightly based on regional and international standards. However, common specifications include a tensile strength of 400 to 550 MPa and a yield strength around 250 MPa. It typically has a density of 7.85 g/cm³ and elongation in the range of 20-30%.

What is Mild Steel Used For?

Thanks to its affordability and ease of processing, mild steel is found in numerous applications. Some common uses of mild steel include:

• Construction materials such as beams, bars, and structural frameworks
• Automotive body panels
• Furniture frames
• Pipelines and tubes
• Agricultural and industrial machinery
• Domestic appliances

What is mild steel used for? Primarily, it's used in projects that require flexibility, easy welding, and shaping rather than extreme strength or wear resistance.

What is Carbon Steel?

Carbon steel is an umbrella term for steels in which carbon is the primary alloying element. Its carbon content can range from 0.05% up to 2.1%, and it’s generally categorized into three types based on this content:

• Low Carbon Steel: Up to 0.3% carbon (similar to mild steel)
• Medium Carbon Steel: 0.3% to 0.6% carbon
• High Carbon Steel: 0.6% to 1.5% carbon

Each variation offers different benefits in terms of strength, hardness, and wear resistance.

What is Carbon Steel Used For?

The uses of carbon steel depend largely on its carbon content. Here's how each type is typically applied:

• Low carbon steel (similar to mild steel) is used for structural applications, pipelines, and general fabrication.
• Medium carbon steel is chosen for parts like gears, axles, and automotive components where strength is critical.
• High carbon steel is used in tools, cutting instruments, springs, and high-strength wires due to its superior hardness and wear resistance.

So, what is carbon steel used for? In short: anything that demands high strength, durability, and wear resistance.

How Strong is Carbon Steel?

The strength of carbon steel varies depending on its carbon content. Low carbon steel is relatively soft and comparable in strength to mild steel, making it easy to shape and weld. In contrast, medium and high carbon steels are significantly stronger, with tensile strengths ranging from 600 to over 1200 MPa. This makes them well-suited for heavy-duty uses such as construction, automotive components, and industrial machinery. However, as the strength increases, the material becomes less ductile and more challenging to weld or machine.

Mild Steel vs Carbon Steel: What's the Difference?

Although mild steel is technically a form of low carbon steel, in industry parlance, it is often treated as a distinct category due to its unique behavior and applications. The core difference lies in the carbon content and the resulting material characteristics.

• A. Carbon Content: Mild steel contains up to 0.25% carbon, while carbon steel may have up to 2.1%. As carbon content increases, the steel becomes harder and stronger but also more brittle and difficult to work with.
• B. Strength and Hardness: Carbon steel, particularly high carbon steel, is significantly harder and stronger than mild steel. This makes it ideal for cutting tools and mechanical parts.
• C. Ductility and Weldability: Mild steel's lower carbon content makes it more ductile and easier to weld. It can be shaped and joined with minimal risk of cracking.
• D. Cost and Availability: Mild steel is generally less expensive and more readily available than high carbon steel, making it the preferred choice for cost-sensitive projects.
• E. Fabrication and Machining: Mild steel is easier to machine and fabricate, whereas carbon steel, particularly high carbon steel, may require specialized tools and processes.

Read Also: Mild Steel vs. Stainless Steel: What is the Difference?

Carbon Steel and Mild Steel: Choosing the Right One

The choice between carbon steel and mild steel should be based on your project's specific requirements. Here's how to approach it:

• If your application needs superior strength, high wear resistance, or hardness, carbon steel—especially medium or high carbon variants—is likely the better choice.
• If your project requires easy forming, welding, and cost-efficiency, mild steel will usually serve you better.

Think about the operating environment, expected loads, machining requirements, and budget. These factors will guide your decision.

Real-World Applications

To better understand the practical use cases of each material, consider the following scenarios:

• A construction company building residential homes may opt for mild steel for structural supports and reinforcements because it's cost-effective and easy to work with.
• An automotive manufacturer producing crankshafts and axle beams might choose medium carbon steel due to its strength and ability to withstand mechanical stress.
• A tool manufacturer requiring material for cutting blades or chisels will likely go for high carbon steel because of its hardness and durability.

Corrosion Resistance and Protection

It's important to note that both mild steel and carbon steel are prone to rust when exposed to moisture and oxygen. Neither material has inherent corrosion resistance. To combat this, additional treatments such as galvanization, powder coating, or painting are often used.

If corrosion resistance is critical for your project, you may want to consider alternative steel types such as stainless steel, which contains chromium and resists rusting.

Common Misconceptions

“Mild steel is inferior to carbon steel”

Not necessarily. Mild steel is purposefully designed for ease of use, ductility, and affordability. Its lower strength isn't a flaw—it's a feature for many types of projects.

“Carbon steel is always better because it's stronger”

Strength isn't the only metric that matters. Carbon steel may be stronger, but it is also harder to weld and more brittle in high-carbon forms. The best steel for a job isn't always the strongest—it's the one that meets all your requirements, including flexibility, machinability, and cost.

Conclusion

So, which one should you use: mild steel or carbon steel?

Use mild steel if:

• Your project requires flexibility, ease of shaping, or frequent welding.
• Budget is a constraint and moderate strength is sufficient.
• You're working on structural frames, pipelines, or automotive body parts.

Use carbon steel if:

• Your application demands high strength, hardness, or wear resistance.
• The material will be under high mechanical stress or repetitive impact.
• You’re manufacturing tools, heavy machinery, or high-performance parts.

Ultimately, the best steel is the one that aligns with your technical, operational, and budgetary needs.